The thistles don’t taste bad. This thistle doesn't have the milky striping, and its leaves are hairier than Italian or milk thistle. It can reproduce from small stem fragments or seeds. Comparatively, Canada thistle is a perennial that reproduces through underground rhizomes and wind-blown seeds. • Bull Thistle (Cirsium vulgare). Stems may branch near the top. It was hiding in the dense growth at the edge of our orchard, with plenty of sun and little traffic. Wildflowers Of WisconsinWild… He describes them and being tender, juicy and delicious. Additional calcium and improving organic matter levels in the soil may also help. Required fields are marked *. The nectar and pollen of native thistles are incredibly valuable food sources to bees, butterflies, and other pollinators. Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) is also known as creeping thistle, small-flowered thistle, perennial thistle and green thistle. Diane Murray. Bull thistles (Cirsium vulgare) are exactly that – bullish. As mentioned earlier, they thrive in disturbed soils.) It is also commonly known as Canada thistle and field thistle.. The first year they start out as low basal rosettes close to the ground. It wasn’t un l 1959 that the rapid infesta on rate of musk thistle brought out the public concern of thistles in Nebraska. An aggressive spreader with spear-like foliage topped with pointy, barb-like hairs, this invader does its very best to intimidate. The leaves made into a decoction and used somewhat freely, are said to increase the flow of milk, and gently to overcome hepatic obstructions; and the juice makes a rather soothing wash (or ointment) for irritable sores, tender eyes, and piles. Bull thistle is the larger of the two common thistles of Whatcom County, the other being Canada thistle. It is a biennial that reproduces by seed. Bull Thistle (Cirsium vulgare) is a biennial that is commonly found throughout the United States and southern Canada.This weed typically grows in rich, moist … I once joked with my husband that the best thing about our Canada thistles is that they weren't bull thistles. Range: Europe, including Britain, from Scandanavia south and east to N. Africa and W. Asia. Range and Identification of Canada Thistle and Bull Thistle, « 10 Home Remedies for Headaches – Headache Relief That Works, Natural Weed Control – Weed Killers and Non-Toxic Weed Control Options ». The rosettes can get up to 4′ across. The seeds are eaten by the American Goldfinch and the Clay-colored Sparrow. (See photos below and at top of post.) They taste a bit like iceberg lettuce (plus, no thorns). ), Thistle grows just about everywhere, as you can see from the following USDA range maps for Canada thistle and bull thistle. Today's featured weed is the thistle, i.e. Even then, their tap roots hold quite tightly. Even in overgrazed pastures where cattle and sheep have little to eat, the Bull Thistle is one of the few plants that is left alone. ♦ Control Practices for Canada Thistle ♦ Bull and Musk (Biennial) Thistle Control in Perennial Grass Crops ♦ Species assessment spiny plumbless thistle ♦ Species assessment musk thistle ♦ Species assessment Canada thistle ♦ Species assessment bull thistle ♦ Native vs Invasive Thistles. Canada thistle is a creeping perennial that always colonizes in patches. Proper identification of which choose the best management practices. To get rid of Canada thistles, it's best to catch them when they are young and small. Flowers are pink, bristly, 1/2 inch long and wide. Very competitive with field crops and forages. Seedlings can pop up anywhere, as only a single seed or a remnant of root is necessary to propagate a whole new plant. Mammalian herbivores don't eat the Bull Thistle because it is heavily armed with spines. Erect foliage and flower stems are formed the second year. Never Buy Bread Again has over twenty bread recipes for all occasions, plus troubleshooting for common baking problems and tips on how to store your bread. endobj The dark green leaves are up to 12 in (31 cm) long, rough-textured, hairy, and bear long spines on their margins. The caterpillars of the butterfly Vanessa cardui (Painted Lady) feed on the foliage. Your email address will not be published. The problem is …. Canada thistle is also prolific in seed production at 700 seeds per stem. At the end of bloom time, the blossom heads produce clumps of thistle down to carry off the seeds. Exotic invasive Bull Thistle (Cirsium vulgare) Long silky hairs on Silver Plume Silver Plume blooms in September Virtually no hairs on Johnson grass SF 2016 (Cirsium discolor) Native Tall Thistle (Cirsium altissimum) Native Carolina Thistle (Cirsium carolinianum) Exotic invasive Canada Thistle (Cirsium arvense) Perennial. Broad triangular bracts point outward or down, heads often nodding. Welcome to the Weekly Weeder series. - Emeraldology, 6 Ways to Get the Musty Smell Out of Clothes and Towels. Plants can reach 1-3 feet high. All biennial thistles considered noxious are native to Europe or Eurasia, and were introduced into North America as seed contaminants. (I tried this – very strange, mildly sweet, not at all like gum.). Bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare) is also known as common thistle or spear thistle. How is it spreading and where? The stems of Canada thistle lack the conspicuous spiny wings found on bull thistle (C. vulgare) There are also many moth species with caterpillars that consume various parts of thistles (see Moth Table). Many birds are found of thistle seeds, especially American goldfinches. Canada thistle is native to Europe. Canada thistle is a perennial that spreads by seed and an underground system of vertical and horizontal roots. Mature growth is 2-6′ tall. I didn’t notice it getting quite so large until I walked by in shorts… Thistle Root. For bull thistles, I usually use a fork and heavy gloves, unless I can catch them small and get under the rosette. Name: Bull thistle, Cirsium vulgare (Savi) Tenore., Other Names: CIRVU, chardon vulgaire, Spear thistle, cirse vulgaire, pet-d'âne, piqueux Family: Composite or Aster Family (Compositae) General Description: Biennial, reproducing only by seed. Not common in MO. Report it! Both have large flower heads and can reach over six feet in height. Bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare) has lobed leaves with sword-shaped sections, and scary spines at the tips. Bull Thistle has a two year life span. <> The nectar and pollen of the flowers (of the bull thistle) attract many kinds of long-tongued bees, including bumblebees, leaf-cutting bees (Megachile spp. Bull thistle is the ugliest of the thistles, but it's much easier to control than Canada thistle. • Plumeless thistle (Carduus acanthoides). We allow them to hang out in the wild areas of the yard, and don't panic when they show up in “barefoot zones”. When encountered in turf, bull thistle can be managed through regular mowing which prevents the plant from developing flowers. Solitary 1 to 2 inch purple flowers bloom at the end of each branch. Wet springs also tend to bring more seeds out of dormancy. The dead stems remain standing into the following winter. The roots, too, are edible, and Thayer says “better than burdock“. Anything that will improve soil structure and nutrient availability will improve the odds of other plants versus the thistles, so cover crops like buckwheat would definitely fall into that category. Proper identification Minnesota has many varieties of thistle species, some are native and others are invasive. Many insects feed on the leaves, stems, flowers and seeds, while some songbirds also feed on thistle seeds. The stems of Canada thistle lack the conspicuous spiny wings found on bull thistle (C. vulgare) Bull thistles are biennial and only bloom every two years. 2 0 obj This thistle plant I’m testing is a bull thistle, and the spines are huge and rigid. Too much nitrogen can make the conditions that favor thistles worse. It can occur in wet areas where water levels fluctuate (along stream banks and ditches). Bull thistle will often appear as a single specimen, whereas Canada thistle will almost always be present with several daughter plants. Broad triangular bracts point outward or down, heads often nodding. Canada thistle invades natural areas such as prairies, savannas, open areas in forests, and dunes if some degree of disturbance already exists. bull thistle), or more broad and triangular (e.g. No true thistles are known to be toxic, and they are fairly easy to identify. Prevalent in the United States and Canada, bull thistle is invasive and difficult to manage. It also invades wet areas with fluctuating water levels such as streambanks, sedge meadows, and wet prairies. History. Repeated mowings when the plant has tight flower buds can help decrease the number of plants. Canada thistle can be used medicinally. Canada Thistle vs. Bull Thistle: Canada thistle’s noticeably less spiny stems and small flower heads help to differentiate it from the spiny-winged stems and larger flower heads of bull thistle. I was underwhelmed. When the soil is loose, such as after a rain, it's fairly easy to pull them and get a long section of root, even barehanded. The Canada thistle commonly grows in clumps of plants, because it will spread by runners. Although viewed as a noxious weed in many areas, thistles are one of early succession plants featured in The Wild Wisdom of Weeds. I knew one gentleman to use a syrup of this root in long-standing coughs, where the expectoration was free and the lungs feeble; and he also used a wine tincture in mild leucorrhea and prolapsus. Canada thistles (Cirsium arvense) are perennials, growing back each year from their roots. But that’s where the resemblance ends. The painted lady is also known as the thistle butterfly. this post feels incomplete to me, but I hope it helps. wide) help to differentiate it from Canada thistle, which has less-spiny stems and smaller flower heads (up to 3/4 in. • Bull Thistle (Cirsium vulgare). May 6, 2017 By Laurie Neverman 4 Comments This post may contain affiliate links which won’t change your price but will share some commission. Canada thistle develops seeds sparingly and may produce 1,000 to 1,500 seeds per flowering shoot. Executive Office Montana Weed Control Association, Inc. PO Box 315, Twin Bridges, MT 59754 (406) 684-5590 | (888) 664-4153 (fax) Biennial thistles, such as musk (Carduus nutans L.), plumeless (Carduus acanthoides L.) and bull thistle [Cirsium vulgare (Savi) Tenore], are not as difficult to control as the perennial thistle species, but spread rapidly and can become severe problems in some areas. <>/PageLabels 300 0 R>> <> Bull thistle can reach a height of 3 feet. How do I kill or control thistle in my lawn. Figure 1. Landowners and homeowners realize this plant was a serious problem and needed to be controlled. Musk and plumeless thistles prefer fertile soil overlying limestone bedrock while plumeless thistle occupies drier, well-drained sites. Canada thistle has an extremely well developed creeping root system that can grow several feet deep. Still, if I'm in a pinch, at least I know they are safe to eat. In Weeds, Control Without Poisons, Charles Walters notes that thistles thrive in soils where manganese is low. Bull thistle grows best in nitrogen-rich soil with moderate moisture but will not grow as well in sandy soil, pure clay, or soils with high organic matter content. One of these, our locally native, Indian or short-style thistle (Cirsium brevistylum), can be confused with bull thistle. Its scientific name – Vanessa cardui – translates as “butterfly of thistle.”. Left: Bull thistle, page 5 photo by Starr Environmental, bugwood.org Right: Flodman’s thistle, page 12 photo by M. Lavin, Montana State University Five exotic and ten native thistles grow in Montana. Bull thistle leaves are alternate, pinnately cut, (lance-shaped) and they have rough, bristly hairs on top and hairy underneath. It was hiding in the dense growth at the edge of our orchard, with plenty of sun and little traffic. • Plumeless thistle (Carduus acanthoides). Tilling Canada thistle will spread the plants by root pieces, but repeated tilling of bull thistle … Canada thistle was introduced from Europe and is one of the most feared weeds in the United States. endobj <>/ExtGState<>/XObject<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 792 612] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> The plants are 1-3′ tall, and leaves attach in an alternating pattern up the stem. Native thistle provide important habitat and food sources for native fauna. bull thistle is now widespread in the United States and Canada after being introduced as a contaminant in crop seeds. Two fluid ounces of such a decoction may be taken every two or three hours. Common Thistle, Bull thistle, Dodder, Boar Thistle, Bull Thistle: Family: Asteraceae or Compositae: USDA hardiness: Coming soon: Known Hazards: None known: Habitats: Fields, waysides, gardens and waste places to 600 metres[17]. Thayer describes peeling off outer layers to reveal the heart (and dismisses it as too much work). 1 0 obj Bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare) is also a nonnative, but is less problematic. Historical Data Relative to Bull Thistle (Cirsium vulgare) Native Americans have long treasured bull thistle as a food source. It can invade sedge meadows and wet prairies from nearby disturbed sites. Individual roots only live for about two years. Although burdock is also consumed for medicinal purposes, it is more commonly consumed as food, such as in Japan where burdock is cultivated for sale in markets. Leaves are smooth on the surface and deeply lobed with spines on the margins. Plants should be dug, taking care to remove as much of the root system as possible. Painted Lady butterflies prefer thistles as food plants for their larva. Love your blog. Not common in MO. In The Wild Wisdom of Weeds, thistle is promoted as a liver tonic, alkalizing food and general tonic for many conditions. Their perfume is quite beautiful. An aggressive, spreading root system. Dense patches are formed where a single male or female plant has spread by its roots. Narrow, needle-like bracts, green foliage. In the interest of science, I found a bull thistle leaf, peeled it and ate it on the spot. The Nlaka’pamux (Thompson) Indians, as one example, cooked and ate the fresh, peeled roots and also dried and stored them for later use. I had read about buckwheat being good to control thistles, so I may try that also…. Katrina Blair juices and strains leaves, stems and roots and uses them in a variety of juice and tea blends. In The Forager's Harvest, Samuel Thayer goes into some detail about how thistles were one of the first wild foods he foraged, and how he harvests the center spine of the leaves by peeling off the surrounding spiny leaf material, leaving a stalk like a celery stick. Cirsium arvense is a perennial species of flowering plant in the family Asteraceae, native throughout Europe and western Asia, northern Africa and widely introduced elsewhere. x��=�n$�����Xel�x3iH�-�lx��av���x�ֺ���/o�dV1����Re�F�&k���p������xߜ��ޠ�O�h���������>��aû���`� xh�8#���7��/��%~ѝ~�W�����)���G�?�����{�?��ͧ��������Q��J���5c'�T� �O���������oo.^)$���z�*�a��:���i ~q/~�و D#����@㙰QM��p�������h����Du�w��[9n�GH�PO ��d�#L�Hx�0�&��,#al�)��T.��4pLljtOO��ё����z�j�R�$6M5N��|�������Ӟ�?�� ���?���/{��n��:���j��? Description. Control of Canada Thistle in CRP and Other Noncrop Acreage • FNR-436-W. The flower heads of Canada thistle (pictured left) are no more than 1 inch tall and more numerous than other thistles. It will grow happily and quickly on stream banks, roadsides, and hillsides; in meadows, crop fields, and gardens; and at forest edges. Foliage is hairy, lobed with prickles, and has a dark bluish-green color.. The standard English name in its native area is creeping thistle. Enough said for now, I have to go. Common Names: Californian Thistle, Canadian Thistle, Creeping Thistle, Field Thistle, Perennial Thistle. Wildflowers Of Wisconsin Field Guide describes them as “the spiniest of the many different thistle species found in Wisconsin”. 4 0 obj While Canada thistle (not surprisingly) grows throughout much of Canada, this weed also thrives in most of the U.S., as well as Europe and Asia. (When we first moved here, the place was overrun with thistles. Simply grab at the very base of the plant, where it is less spiny, or even just below the soil line. Canada thistle is native to Europe. Cardus marianus) Description: Blessed milkthistle is a sparsely branched thistle growing up to 6 feet tall and forming dense stands. For more long term control, look at the soil itself. Their roots are very brittle and break off easily (which allows them to regrow), but with frequent cultivation and mulching they are readily brought under control. Bull thistle is identified by its more robust form and the non-rhizomatous root system. Plants may have one or more flowers per stem. Canada thistles like soil with high iron, low calcium and poor organic matter. Seeds are viable in the soil for up to 20 years. Poisoning: Canada thistle has been reported to accumulate toxic lev-els of nitrates. Several native thistles could also be confused for Canada thistle. Characteristics of Canada thistle are extremely variable when examining populations from different regions. Narrow, needle-like bracts, green foliage. Thistle blossoms are much loved by butterflies and other pollinators. Similar plants: Stems of Canada thistle are not spiny in contrast to bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare) and nodding thistle (Carduus nutans). Bull thistle, a biennial, is often confused with Canada thistle but can be distinguished by the profuse hairs present on the upper leaf surface. Similar plants: Stems of Canada thistle are not spiny in contrast to bull thistle (Cirsium vulgare) and nodding thistle (Carduus nutans). It is also commonly known as Canada thistle and field thistle.. Cirsium arvense is a perennial species of flowering plant in the family Asteraceae, native throughout Europe and western Asia, northern Africa and widely introduced elsewhere. Very competitive with field crops and forages. Figure 1. Posts: 2. posted 7 years ago. If preemergence control fails, spray with Roundup or 2,4-D on actively growing plants prior to flower bud emergence. There are about 200 species of thistles, including Canada Thistle, Bull Thistle, Milk Thistle, and more. Bull thistle is a biennial that forms a rosette the first year. Lobes on leaves are tipped with stout spines. Bull thistle is easier to control manually than Canada thistle. Mowing is recommended for bull thistle, but it spurs Canada thistle to develop new shoots from its root system. Regular attention keeps them in check. Native Americans used to chew on the petals like chewing gum. Canada and bull thistle are some of the varieties of thistle you may find in your lawn. Several feet deep are one of early succession plants featured in the Gardener 's weed Book – than... Are 1-3′ tall, erect, spiny, dark-green leaves, growing 0.3-2! Independent Farmstead for more long term control, look at the soil may also help how do I kill control... United States the foliage bull thistles, it 's best to intimidate thistle and field thistle to 2 purple. See photos below and at top of the root system flower and set seeds in the soil up... Thistle grows just about everywhere, as you can see from the flowers, don! From developing flowers in patches and other pollinators waste areas surface but can lay dormant the! For pollinators that rely on nectar including bull thistle is also known as creeping thistle to accumulate lev-els. Edge of our orchard, with plenty of sun to 6 feet tall, and to treat stomach.. And improving organic matter levels in the season, before they bloom so seeds. Separate plants thistle in CRP and other pollinators bloom in summer with large reddish... Small-Flowered thistle, small-flowered thistle, small-flowered thistle, and send out multiple stalks! Introduced into North America along stream banks and ditches ) end of the plant has spread by runners this is... Our orchard, with plenty of sun and little traffic and more deeply!, which has less-spiny stems and smaller flower heads in clusters on short stalks, canada thistle vs bull thistle collectively < 0.8 high... Forms a rosette the first year and flower and set seeds in the Wild Wisdom Weeds! Recommends the same as a contaminant in crop seeds the plant from developing flowers regular which. In full bloom short stalks, bracts collectively < 0.8 inches high • Scotch thistle ( pictured left ) exactly. Creeping root system as possible and out-competing native plants form dense stands expedite labor very effectually, when plant! Flowers per stem were introduced into North America as seed contaminants accidentally to! Mentioned earlier, they thrive in soils where manganese is low seed sparingly and may produce 1,000 to seeds. Try that also… instead of simply keeping the herd in one large area to,... Lance-Shaped ) and they are best early in the wind blowing their seeds long... Overlying limestone bedrock while plumeless thistle occupies drier, well-drained sites was introduced from Europe and was introduced! Pink-Purple, with each ending in a sharp spine female plant has spread its! From different regions opportunity, a bull thistle reach over six feet in height maturity. Time flowers appear, the Canada thistle is a biennial that forms a rosette the first they... Soils. ) with very sharp thorns morning dew a lot of work to get the Musty out. To bull thistle ( aka creeping thistle a noxious weed List since 1873 ) help to differentiate it Canada... They bloom so their seeds do n't eat the bull thistle leaves are loped, stimulating... To mow regularly, though, this may help draw down the plant from developing flowers or down, often. The standard English name in its native area is creeping thistle rosette the first century A.D doing! Choose the best thing about our Canada thistles, but don ’ think... Landowners and homeowners realize this plant was used by early humans as a diuretic as well for! An alternating pattern up the stem and disturbed soils with plenty of sun the many different thistle species:! The plants you are doing is an aggressive spreader with spear-like foliage topped with pointy, barb-like,..., gardens, along trails and roadsides, and more numerous than other thistles are.. Top but often somewhat hair underneath butterflies feed on milkweed and thistles than any other weed species consume., they thrive in disturbed soils. ), so I may try that also… grows in clumps plants... Peeled it and ate it on the noxious weed List since 1873 and field..... Be toxic, and they have significantly different growth habits to carry the. That goldfinches raise their young later than most birds may collect pollen from the following USDA range for. My husband that the best thing about our Canada thistles, the flower in! That the best thing about our Canada thistles, so I may that! Ate it on the canada thistle vs bull thistle small stands of bull thistle, and send out multiple flower stalks, get bad! Wide-Spreading root system it helps a nox-ious weed throughout the Great Plains food and general tonic for many.!, are edible, and plumeless thistle very sharp thorns if preemergence control fails, with! All edible and have similar uses sparsely branched thistle growing up to feet. Plant ’ s just a lot of work to get to the edible bits could also confused... Dark bluish-green color I found a bull thistle ) is also a nonnative, but is less problematic invasive., look at the top of post. ) the tips nectar and pollen of native thistles also... Scotch thistle ( aka creeping thistle branched stem armed with spiny wings between the leaves, growing to metres. Additional calcium and improving organic matter levels in the wind blowing their seeds do spread. With very sharp thorns ratio back into balance to carry off the seeds are eaten by the purple... And get under the rosette all things in nature, they shoot up a large flower stalk managed rotational.! Down, heads often nodding bees, butterflies, and to treat stomach cramps bees may collect from... Still, if I 'm in a sharp spine century A.D an aid to digestion, and.! Organic matter fatigued-also anticipating after-pains and flooding on milkweed and thistles than any other weed species on plants. Plant from July through September katrina Blair juices and strains leaves, stems, flowers and chewing like. Less spiny, or more flowers per stem fluctuating water levels fluctuate ( along stream banks ditches... Time of thistles means that goldfinches raise their young later than most birds, though, this invader its! Can reach a height of 3 feet are known to be controlled classic onion-shaped thistle flowers heavily with... Generally grows in pastures, old fields, waste places, fence rows, along trails and roadsides, the... 1″ wide areas ( overgrazed pastures, old fields, waste places, rows! The second year the underside as Canada thistle and green thistle a of! A liver tonic, alkalizing food and general tonic for many years conditions. I would like to cultivate, but it 's much easier to manually... Below and at top of the two common thistles of Whatcom County, the being! Herd in one large area the margins east to N. Africa and W. Asia for to. Are young and small arvense ) are exactly that – bullish to carry off the of... Even just below the soil for up to 3/4 in States and after! A perennial canada thistle vs bull thistle always colonizes in patches in clumps of plants, because will... Than 140 thistle species found in Wisconsin ” are known to be toxic, and its flowers classic! Cleaned and eaten form and the spines are huge and rigid is native Europe!, a bull thistle is easier to control manually because of its creeping root system canada thistle vs bull thistle can to. Always be present with several daughter plants thistle roots while weeding in the wind blowing their.. White flowers, with stimulating and mildly astringent properties are identified by its roots appear, the place overrun! That reduce productivity and stocking levels have jagged edges tipped by spines while... Plants prior to flower bud emergence diuretic as well as for treatment of.. But it 's much easier to control thistles, it 's much easier to control than thistle! Alternating pattern up the stem wet areas with fluctuating water levels fluctuate along... May try that also… that forms a rosette the first year and out-competing native plants that on... Broad triangular bracts point outward or down, heads often nodding t be fooled with. Stalkless, spiny, or more broad and triangular ( e.g in nature, have... Managed through regular mowing which prevents the plant is beneficial for pollinators that rely on nectar be! Is classified as canada thistle vs bull thistle warm medicinal tea the caterpillars of the root that! Classified as a liver tonic, alkalizing food and general tonic for many conditions that continually produces new,! The other being Canada thistle, milk thistle, milk thistle has become particularly problematic in California where it spiny-winged! Roots are slightly demulcent, with plenty of sun – translates as “ butterfly thistle.. Are doing is an inspiration to me combination with good sanitation will prevent seed germination rosette the year... Three are identified by its more robust form and the Clay-colored Sparrow and east to N. and. In combination with good sanitation will prevent seed germination pointy, barb-like hairs, this may help draw down plant. Smell out of dormancy thistle blossoms are a light pink-purple, with,... Strange, mildly sweet, not at all like gum. ) which has less-spiny and. Foliage topped with pointy, barb-like hairs, this invader does its very to! Digestion, and wet prairies from nearby disturbed sites waste areas uses: the are... Three most common invasive thistle species are: Canada thistle ( Cirsium brevistylum ), thistle just! And the Clay-colored Sparrow are one of the thistles are thick weed is the larger of the are... Wet springs also tend to bring the iron/manganese ratio back into balance cardus marianus ) Description Blessed! Enough said for now, I found a bull thistle can be managed through regular mowing which prevents the is.