And I sort of think that they're winging it more than a neo-classical guitarist who is thinking more in a mathematical way. Thanks! Most of the answers here, however, deal with the different kinds of music you play on them. save. Modern De Lucia inspired flamenco. Reading sheet music is probably one of the most arduous and tedious tasks of playing classical music. The exaggerated vibrato is tricky, but not as tricky as the inability to throw notes away, which is a key element of pop and jazz – singing through all the notes kills the swing. Jazz is a music genre that originated in the African-American communities of New Orleans, Louisiana, United States, in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, with its roots in blues and ragtime. My Jazz teacher was a total "tosser" as you call them. report. Musically, I say the edge goes to jazz. These gray-haired classical music lovers seem to continue to love classical music (there is evidence, according to Dempster, that people are more attracted to classical music in middle age than in their youth), but if you’re a teen and your mom and dad love something, chances are good that you’ll, if not outright hate it, at least think it’s pretty lame. Where the two differ - noting that DS has chosen the jazz route for Trinity, not the classical one - is the range of skills he is required to / has the choice to show on top of the pieces. I'm grade 8 ANZCA classical, same as grade 8 ABRSM and Grade 9,10 RCM,and sometimes, for fun, I'll play some jazz, boogie woogie or blues pieces of the same grade. I voted Jazz but probably more because I have a soft spot for it over classical. After that they wouldn't say hello to me when I passed them in the street. Some times he misses the boat. I was curious if there was any jazz as hard as high level Liszt pieces etc? I think you could probably get to be proficient on either a guitar or piano within a couple of years if you practiced reasonably regularly. Upload or insert images from URL. This is an easy way to tell difference between this types of guitars. Someone asked me this the other day and I really didn't have an answer, probably because I don't know how to play either style. Except that there's also a lot of creativity in that seemingly perfect interpretation. Piano Classical sounds harder than piano Jazz? I was a lazy bastard and I managed it, and it wasn't particularly in my genes or anything like that. If you have a bluesy way of playing like I do it came much easier.. Wouldn't even know where to start with Classical:confused: But it probably isn't rocket science to become 'proficient' as a classical player. Long answer is I do both often and neither is a walk in the park. The classical tenor player may find the most success with a Selmer S80 C**, a Selmer S90 180, or a Vandoren Optimum TL3. 0 0 1. Eddie Daniels is both a jazz and classical musician. The one catch - and this is coming from someone who has never attempted a classical piece - is that jazz requires improvisation whereas classical does not (as far as I am aware). All that proves is how few people you know. Some people may be more easily able to learn one style over another style. Their brains showed more awareness of the fingering, and as a result they made fewer errors while playing. Such a blend of musical elements was not entirely new: by 1924 both Milhaud and Gershwin had composed classical works that incorporated elements of jazz Johnson, a serious musician more experienced than most classical composers with jazz, blues, spirituals, and popular music, was particularly suited to expand Milhaud's and Gershwin's experiments. Answer. The body shape of the acoustic guitar is different than classical guitar. But inside they feel all smug and pleased. Was it hard? Play some Rock or Blues instead - you'll stop worrying about what's harder to play and become listenable at the same time. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account. Is it still easy? You don't. It is responsive. A jazz pianist has a difficult time to find their voice because of all of these creative parts of jazz. Ergo - guitar is harder, for jazz. There's no right or wrong answer there. Totally different animals, but I like the idea. That said, despite all of that, I still think that the level of dedication and technique and knowledge required to play yngwie-style stuff is much greater than that required to play blues. However, the classical pianists performed better than the jazz group when it came to following unusual fingering. Yes No. Classical music can be considered to cover a time span that covers over a millennium. Xenakiboy. You have jacked up classical technique and extensive improvisation. Scott what's his name. If reading music comes naturally to you, then jazz is easier. Posted by 3 years ago. So, lets say, it was reletively easy for you..... O.K. Playing classical music is extremely hard. The overall dynamic of jazz is much louder than that of classical music, at least at the chamber music level. But when I listen to jazz, they don't use that many notes and I could play a song way quicker than a metal or classical song, yet people say it is hard. Studies based on scales / arpeggios rather than scales / arpeggios themselves. I can't understand how jazz is the slightest bit complicated, metal is way more complicated than jazz no matter how I think of it. Both the classical and jazz guitar requires a lot of skill. By Both forms of music will withstand time equally as well 5. Classical requires the ability to sight read, while jazz requires the ability to creatively process musical ideas, to understand, instead of simply translating from page. When I think jazz, I'm thinking of guys like Joe Pass, Scotty Anderson, etc.. And classical too, because music that is beginner stuff for piano is high level for guitar. But then to counter my own argument...to take a previously written classical piece and give it your own sound..well that's pretty amazing too. In classical music the distinction between composer (or creator of music) and performer is highly divided - only in specific instances is the performer allowed to improvise (in the historical practice of music from the Renaissance, Baroque, classical piano concertos by Mozart and others, and certain 20th/21st century classical music). Classical vs Jazz Music. Though the modern pieces are of the same difficulty as the classical pieces, I feel like jazz pieces just sound easier, is it just me? If you have a good ear, then classical is easier. They are different, but with enough practice a decent guitar player can play classical. 8. With my classical playing, I am constantly trying to speak while interpreting what is already written. guitarman3001, November 9, 2009 in Electric Guitars. Listen to a number of different players play a difficult piece of repertoire (Bach's Chaconne, etc), and listen to how they play it. I can understand the "it's impossible to say/completely different disciplines" view. Mind you, that was in Cambridge - a town full of arrogant and socially crippled wankers. OK, it’s hard to narrow these down to just one - but Berio’s experimental Sequenzas were actually designed to push the boundaries of what might be possible with any given instrument. Which is harder: Classical Mechanics or Quantum Mechanics? read more. In general, I would say it's much harder to improvise a jazz solo than to perform an already-written classical work. Because it’s more popular than you think. View Profile I see jazz through dim glasses: in a way it's harder, because I am a classical player. There is always another level of hardness in anything we do, so it is impossible to quantify a level of hardness for anything dealing with the performing of music. But anyone who says jazz is better because of its complexity doesn't understand music. This focus on chords is the main area where contemporary piano technique differs from classical piano. The brass section would just sit there and be pissed that they picked a ghay instrument to play.. Like I said, it was cool. These choices not only include a multitude of artists, but also a wide diversity of music categories. Classical requires the ability to sight read, while jazz requires the ability to creatively process musical ideas, to understand, instead of simply translating from page. Ask a Question. Source: shinemusic.com.au. Well what ever level of hardness you assign to it, someone may have found it easier than you did. People who have no training, or experience in music have absolutely no problem answering this question. ... which is about three times harder than Silver Maple. Rock, folk, blues. Agree completely. Julian Bream's playing and interpretation just blow my mind, and I'd rather listen to him than just about anyone on any style of guitar. You have to be the master of your trade, fully confident in your skills and versed in theory if you want to be a classical guitarist. It is going to be an individual thing and only the person attempting these two styles will be able to let us know. I play a very wide range of genres of instruments, from metal guitar in a jam session, jazz guitar, alto sax, latin piano, rock, classical, etc... so I have experience with a lot of things. Sight reading includes being completely fluent in reading rhythm as well as melody. I still really respect and enjoy jazz. Scaruffi.com states that classical music has many more nuances to style than modern music. I started classical piano when I was 6 and got to grade 7. Classical, guys like Segovia, etc. What style is harder to become proficient in? Picking for jazz can be introduced in other styles, but there's really nowhere other than classical to pick up that kind of fingerpicking technique. I know no people who listen to Classical or Jazz guitar pieces without playing them. Creativity is big with me and it's an aspect of classical that is missing in my opinion. Be the first to answer! Musically, I say the edge goes to jazz. 19 comments. That's the home turf. Both are very easy to make sounds on, compared with a steel-strung acoustic guitar. But, just because you are proficient in one style doesn't mean you can play another "easier" style well. × How else can you explain why different people can play the same piece and they can be so emotionally different. I like jazz guitar too but am fascinated with neoclassical guitar. Rock, folk, blues. Fast metal shredding seems way more difficult to master than jazz guitar. Creativity with classical guitar is in the interpretation. Everytime he left the room, me (guitar) and the drummer and bassist would break into Metallica or something totally NON-Jazz.. Of course, performing something like a Liszt concerto accurately takes many years of practice, but Lizst has already done a good chunk of the work by writing the notes. Just because they're not inventing a solo doesn't mean that they're not creative. The answer is most likely "it's impossible to say". For solo piano? It has an adjustable truss rod and a lightly radius’d fingerboard and a narrower neck (about 1/8” thinner across the nut than your typical 2” wide classical guitar), but its voice is classical with an open midrange. then, lest see you do it with only one hand. Rock is a much younger form of music than classical 4. This is probably because of the prominence of the drum set in jazz, which is extremely loud compared to any chamber instrument (and has gotten considerably louder with the advent of rock music) and tends to play at a fairly consistent volume. Who doesn't love being #1? And giving it feeling and swing. I'd say you could probably spend more time playing jazz and never get completely comfortable with it while classical is all about disciplined practice. Jazz is a distinctively American form of music, and its history occupies a much smaller span of time.   Your previous content has been restored. Classical pianists base a lot of their strength in the piano from technique where Jazz pianists rely much more on their rhythmic understanding and scales/chord forms and progressions. I think this is what blows it for Yngwie. A classical pianist can generally transfer over to jazz easier than a jazz pianist to classical. share. O.K... so you have mastered all Paganini's Caprices for violin, and maybe Bach's Chaccone too. You just need to have had pushy parents who insisted you play half an hour every evening on something you don't really enjoy, then a slightly effete music teacher with limp wrists to yap at you when you sing the wrong note. And of course, even if no ones heard the classical shred before, it's either right or wrong. While likely easier to play than your royals, on a classical mouthpiece, they will sound thin and airy in addition to bright and buzzy. Jazz is more difficult generally... of the two videos mookid posted, the bach one was far easier to play. A jazz pianist has a difficult time to find their voice because of all of these creative parts of jazz. Jazz also has a much larger scope for improvisation which eludes a lot of classical pianists. For beginners, learning to play acoustic guitar is a bit harder than learning to play classical guitar (though it’s not that hard really). Some guitarists spray a lubricant on the strings that helps make them less abrasive. Form—sonata and rondo, minuet and scherzo, and so forth—needs to be understood before the music can be properly ingested. In my opinion, neither of them is harder than the other although many classical riffs may be a bit more complex as jazz melodies are often created by running scales. Physically or artistically? As for Jazz, there's an awful lot of variations. read more, Surprisingly enough that is not an easy question to answer because it really totally depends on how you were taught, or not taught, to play music. anything can only be as hard or easy as you make it. So I'd say jazz is harder. But I've also seen some very impressive classical guitar. 0 0. 3. Display as a link instead, × The jazz guy might be able to cover his improvizational meanderings. read more. The classical period of music actually spans a time from of 1750 to 1800; thus, the term Classical is a misnomer and could more correctly be changed to Western Art Music or European Art Music. 4 Answers. Best jazz guitarists are those who have discovered how to make the guitar work for them, not against them. So in reply I drew a portrait of one of them, which they pretended not to like (probably because it looked like the subject). Relevance. You can post now and register later. Learning complex classical and jazz riffs will take much dedication and practice to master and proper finger technique will dictate how well one can play for both genres. Wynton Marsalis too is known as a performer of classical music, just to make the first examples that I can think of.